MSP vs. VMS: What’s the Difference, and Which is Better for Staffing and Managing Contingent Labor?

MSP vs. VMS: What’s the Difference, and Which is Better for Staffing and Managing Contingent Labor?

/ Managed Microsoft 365 / By

Contingent workers are reshaping the modern workforce, providing companies with flexibility, specialized skills, and cost-effective solutions. A recent report shows that 41% of companies plan to increase their use of contingent workers. This trend highlights how businesses aim to access diverse skills, reduce costs, and use the external workforce as a strategic asset for growth. As industries evolve, contingent workers provide the unique expertise that many companies don’t have in-house. This shift toward contingent hiring highlights the value of adaptable talent in driving growth and resource efficiency. In this blog, we’ll explore the key differences between a Vendor Management System (VMS) and a Managed Service Provider (MSP). We’ll also discuss the numerous benefits of integrating a VMS with an MSP and offer guidance on the steps to take if you’re interested in determining which option is best suited for your company. 

What is a Contingent Worker?

A contingent worker is an independent contractor or freelancer hired by a company for specific tasks or projects. Whether they work on-site or remotely, their status depends on their relationship with the firm assigning the tasks. Contingent workers bring unique perspectives and specialized skills, offering invaluable solutions to complex business challenges. In the evolving landscape of work arrangements, contingent workers are a strategic asset for companies navigating the complexities of the modern labor market. 

What is a Managed Service Provider (MSP)?

A Managed Service Provider (MSP) serves as an outsourced agency that connects third-party vendors with a company that is seeking to hire talent. By partnering with an MSP, businesses can offload specific staffing responsibilities, allowing them to concentrate on their core functions and strategic goals. This collaborative approach not only enhances efficiency but also helps companies access the specialized talent required to drive growth and innovation. Additionally, MSPs assist HR and procurement teams in streamlining recruitment processes, enabling them to focus on more significant responsibilities. 

What is a Vendor Management System (VMS)?

A Vendor Management System (VMS) is a cloud-based software designed to streamline the management of contingent workers. By utilizing a VMS, companies can efficiently manage temporary staffing, staffing suppliers, and other involved parties. This system enables companies to simplify the hiring process by facilitating the review and ranking of job applicants. Additionally, a VMS helps classify hired workers and ensures compliance with necessary requirements, such as valid work permits and relevant accreditations. 

MSP vs. VMS: Key Differences Explained

Managed Service Providers (MSPs) deliver comprehensive management and strategic guidance, making them an excellent choice for organizations seeking hands-on support. In contrast, Vendor Management Systems (VMS) deliver flexibility for businesses that prefer to directly manage their staffing processes. The decision between MSPs and VMS solutions largely depends on a company’s unique needs, size, and available resources. 

The primary distinction between an MSP and a VMS is that an MSP is led by people who leverage technology to enhance service delivery, while a VMS is a software solution that allows businesses to manage their staffing independently, without support from additional resources. Utilizing a centralized location for workforce data and metrics helps automate labor-intensive tasks, such as time tracking and invoicing, streamlining operations and enhancing efficiency. By understanding the advantages of MSPs and VMS, companies can make informed decisions that align with their business goals and staffing needs. Additionally, these technologies can aid HR and procurement leaders in efficiently identifying suitable applicants while freeing them to focus on more strategic tasks. 

Choosing Between a VMS and an MSP

When deciding between a Vendor Management System (VMS) and a Managed Service Provider (MSP) for managing your contingent workers, consider the following: 

  • Contingent Workforce Management: If your primary goal is to manage your contingent workforce, a VMS might be the better choice. It offers tools for procurement, sourcing, and time and expense tracking, making it easier to oversee your contingent workers. 
  • IT Management: If you need to outsource IT management, an MSP could be more suitable. MSPs provide expert IT services, including security, monitoring, and maintenance, ensuring your IT operations run smoothly. 
  • Cost Savings: Both VMS and MSP solutions offer cost savings, but in different ways. A VMS reduces administrative burdens and improves procurement processes, while an MSP helps lower labor costs and optimize resource allocation. Evaluate your specific needs to determine which option provides the most value for your organization. 

Advantages of Integrating VMS with MSP

Integrating Vendor Management Systems with Managed Service Providers offers significant advantages for companies seeking to improve their staffing methods. This integration streamlines workflows, improves visibility into staffing activities, and enhances talent acquisition by leveraging MSP networks. By leveraging machine learning, procurement teams can efficiently identify suitable candidates based on specific criteria, ultimately saving time and allowing team members to concentrate on more strategic responsibilities. It leads to cost efficiency by consolidating vendor relationships, ensures compliance with regulations, and provides data-driven insights for strategic decision-making. Additionally, integrated systems allow for scalability to meet changing workforce demands, foster collaboration between HR teams and MSPs, enable faster response times, and improve the overall quality of hires, ultimately helping organizations meet their staffing needs more effectively. 

Optimize Your Staffing Strategy: How PSM Partners Supports Your Needs for Contingent Labor

PSM offers flexible engagement models that allow businesses to find candidates for short-term projects or hire directly for full-time positions. Whether you need experienced professionals to oversee your IT infrastructure or lead specific initiatives, our team is ready to help. By partnering with us, you’ll gain access to a pool of skilled IT staff, ensuring smooth operations and successful project outcomes for your organization. We apply a consistent approach in every situation to guarantee our clients receive the best resources promptly. At PSM, we take the time to understand your IT requirements and connect you with candidates possessing the precise skills needed for your project. To learn more, call PSM at (312) 940-7830 today. 

Related Insights

About the Author

Picture of Taylor Friend
Taylor Friend

I'm a goal-oriented Strategic Alliance Manager who is enthusiastic about building and nurturing collaborative relationships that drive business success. My commitment lies in establishing, overseeing, and expanding partnerships that generate greater business opportunities and foster revenue growth for all stakeholders.

Together, we make it happen

Tell Us About Your Project.

Don’t hesitate to reach out. Our specialists are ready to help transform your business. 

Let’s talk

Phone

(312) 940-7830

Contact Form
X

(Managed Services, Cloud Services, Consulting, Cybersecurity, Talent)

What is 7+4?