Document Management vs Records Management

Table of Contents

In today’s digital landscape, law firms must ensure that all documents and data are well-organized, easily accessible by users, and compliant with data protection regulations. As organizations handle increasing amounts of content, understanding the difference between document management and records management becomes critical. Whether you’re evaluating a new document management solution or seeking to enhance your current infrastructure with advanced records management capabilities, it’s essential to align your strategy with your firm’s compliance needs and long-term goals. As digital transformation accelerates, investing in the right tools and strategies to manage your data isn’t just a best practice, it’s a competitive advantage.

Legal Records Management: What It Is and Why It Matters

According to ISO 15489, records management is all about controlling the lifecycle of records—from creation to storage to proper disposal—while maintaining accurate proof of business activities. Preserving the authenticity and reliability of permanent records is crucial in this process. This includes important files like contracts, case documents, court filings, and client records, anything essential to the daily operations of a law firm or legal department. Effective records management also plays a crucial role in retrieving documents associated with legal action, such as subpoenas, thereby ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements. As law firms handle sensitive information, legal document management must follow strict security and privacy regulations. Protecting client data while keeping records easily accessible is key.

Key Features of Records Management:

Audit Trails: A strong records management system includes audit trails that track every action taken on a document—who viewed it, when it was edited, and what changes were made. This helps ensure transparency, accountability, and legal compliance. Good records management is essential for the effective handling of essential business information.
Document Security: Security is critical for protecting confidential files. Look for features like access controls, user permissions, and data encryption to prevent unauthorized access to sensitive information.
Retention Schedules: These policies define how long legal documents should be kept and when they should be securely deleted. This helps law firms and legal teams stay compliant with industry regulations and avoid unnecessary data storage costs. Having documented policies and procedures for defensible destruction is crucial, as it enables organizations to justify and prove the processes involved in record destruction, ensuring compliance and mitigating legal risks.

Legal Document Management: What It Is and Why It Matters

Legal document management software—commonly referred to as a Document Management System (DMS) is a cloud-based or on-premises solution designed to help law firms securely store, organize, and retrieve legal documents with ease. Cloud-based document management offers enhanced business continuity and operational efficiency, ensuring data security and disaster recovery. Unlike basic file storage, a robust legal DMS offers powerful search, version control, and collaboration tools for managing electronic documents tailored to the needs of legal professionals. Integrating a legal document management solution with your law firm’s existing software enhances efficiency, streamlines workflows, and supports compliance with legal industry standards. Purpose-built for law firms, a document management system addresses the unique challenges of managing legal files, emails, and case-related materials in today’s fast-paced legal environment.

Key Features of Document Management:

Real-Time Collaboration: Enables multiple users to simultaneously edit and collaborate on documents, boosting teamwork and overall productivity.

A document management system also plays a crucial role in capturing and storing various types of electronic documents alongside digital images of physical documents.

Document Version Control: Guarantees that all users are accessing the latest version of a document, with the ability to track changes and maintain version history.
Enhanced Document Searchability: Simplifies document retrieval with advanced search features, including tags and metadata, ensuring quick access to specific files. These advanced search features significantly enhance information retrieval, improving operational efficiency and compliance with legal requirements.

Three Key Differences Between Records Management and Document Management

While document management and records management both focus on organizing and maintaining information, they play distinct roles in a firm’s information governance strategy. Understanding the difference between document management vs. records management is essential for effective content management. Here are three key areas where they differ:

1. Types of Information Managed

DMS’s are designed to store, track, and manage everyday business documents such as proposals, contracts, emails, and spreadsheets. These documents are often dynamic, subject to frequent updates and collaboration.

Records management, on the other hand, focuses on preserving official records that serve as evidence of business activities, transactions, or compliance—think tax filings, employee records, legal documents, or audit trails. These records are typically static and must be retained for specific periods due to regulatory requirements or industry compliance standards. Additionally, records management includes electronic files, which can take various forms such as documents, multimedia, and other digital records. Proper handling of these files is crucial for compliance with regulations, especially when dealing with sensitive information.

2. Technology and Systems Used

Document management solutions often include features like version control, access permissions, cloud storage integration, and collaboration tools to improve day-to-day workflow and team productivity. Popular platforms include NetDocuments, iManage, SharePoint, and Worldox.

Records management systems (RMS) are built with a strong focus on data retention, security, classification, and defensible disposal. These systems are equipped to support compliance with regulations like HIPAA, SOX, or GDPR and typically include audit trails, metadata tagging, and automated retention schedules.

3. Management Processes and Compliance Requirements

In document management, the emphasis is on efficient document lifecycle management—from creation and review to approval and archiving. These processes prioritize accessibility and version control, enabling teams to work on live documents with minimal friction.

Records management involves stricter controls and processes. Organizations must establish policies for records classification, retention, access control, and destruction in line with legal and regulatory obligations. Proper records management provides organizations control over their information, enabling enhanced strategic planning and fostering compliance with regulations to minimize risks and liabilities associated with sensitive data. Failure to properly manage records can result in legal penalties or data breaches, making compliance a top priority.

Integrating Document and Records Management Systems

Integrating document management and records management systems is essential for maintaining control over sensitive client information and ensuring legal compliance. A unified approach supports a smooth transition from active case files to archived legal records, helping firms manage the complete legal document lifecycle with accuracy and efficiency. A records management program is crucial in streamlining the identification, retrieval, and compliance of documents, ensuring both paper and electronic documents are easily accessible and meet legal and regulatory standards.

With an integrated document and records management system, attorneys and staff can easily collaborate on case documents while ensuring finalized records—such as signed contracts, pleadings, or court filings—are securely stored and retained according to legal records retention policies. Specialized systems designed for managing records are essential for effective electronic records management, adhering to industry standards and frameworks endorsed by various governmental bodies. This not only minimizes risk but also supports compliance with regulations such as ABA guidelines, HIPAA, and other jurisdictional requirements.

Key Steps to Integrate Document and Records Management for Law Firms

Implementing an integrated document and records management strategy is critical for law firms seeking to enhance information governance, improve efficiency, and stay compliant with legal industry standards. A records manager plays a critical role in overseeing the integration process. Here are five essential steps to guide your integration process:

Assess Your Law Firm’s Needs

Start by evaluating your firm’s specific legal document management and records retention requirements. Identify how attorneys, paralegals, and administrative staff use documents daily and determine where document and records management systems can complement each other.

Select the Right Technology Platform

Choose a platform—or integrated solution—that offers robust features for both document collaboration and secure legal records retention. Leading platforms like NetDocuments, iManage, or Microsoft 365 with SharePoint can support hybrid solutions tailored for law firms.

Define Policies and Compliance Procedures

Establish clear guidelines on how documents evolve into records, define records retention schedules, and ensure your processes meet industry regulations such as ABA Model Rules, or HIPPA. Formal management practices are crucial in ensuring efficient access and compliance. Having documented procedures is essential for compliance audits and risk mitigation.

Provide Team Training and Change Management

Educate attorneys and support staff on the differences between document and records management, emphasizing the importance of each in the legal document lifecycle. Training ensures consistent adoption and optimal use of your systems.

Monitor, Audit, and Continuously Improve

Regularly evaluate your firm’s information management practices to identify gaps, ensure system performance, and refine workflows. Ongoing reviews help you stay compliant, efficient, and aligned with evolving legal technology best practices.

Choosing the Right System: PSM's Expertise in Document vs Records Management

For firms, choosing between document management and records management depends on your specific needs and priorities. Document management helps organize and manage active case files, while records management focuses on long-term preservation and ensuring compliance with legal and regulatory requirements. Many law firms find that adopting both document and records management systems is crucial for effective information management. Electronic records management minimizes costs and improves productivity by automating the handling of records from creation to final disposition.

At PSM, we offer IT services tailored to law firms worldwide, helping to manage and secure their IT infrastructure while implementing solutions that enhance their systems. Our law firm IT services are customized to meet your firm’s unique needs and technology objectives. We also focus on helping clients maximize their investment in NetDocuments, ensuring technology solutions align with your firm’s critical business goals. Establishing a records management policy is essential for defining how various records are managed, including decision-making processes related to records creation, usage, storage, and disposal, as well as compliance measures and training for employees. With extensive experience in the legal industry, we provide expert guidance and strategic partnerships to ensure seamless implementation and continued success.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the main difference between document management and records management?

Document management focuses on organizing and collaborating on active documents, while records management involves preserving finalized records for compliance, audits, and long-term access.

Can a law firm use both document and records management systems?

Yes. Most firms benefit from using both. Document management improves workflow and productivity, while records management ensures regulatory compliance and secure, long-term storage of sensitive records.

What are common tools used in legal document or records management?

Popular document management platforms include NetDocuments, iManage, and SharePoint. Records management systems often support compliance features like audit trails, retention policies, and secure destruction processes.

How can PSM Partners help with document and records management?

PSM Partners specializes in legal IT services and helps firms assess, implement, and optimize document and records management systems—ensuring compliance, security, and seamless collaboration.

Related Insights